Bobbyaro wrote:
I think Curiosity is a spy and here's why:
When I* commented on Saturnalian and/or Grim... not being spies I said, "There are four spies so one of Grim... and Saturnalian is definitely not a spy - maybe both."
When Curiosity said it he said, "Hmmmm. Also, given the numbers and where they are, I reckon one of Grim/Sat are probably bad."
Fair enough, but he said this after Cras had announced he was going to take both sat and grim..., as though he was trying to convince Cras not to choose them. the only reason that would be the case is because they aren't spies and he is a dirty spy with a fez, a bomb and a stick of TNT in his trenchcoat.
*not a spy
I'll be properly raging if curio is a spy. The person out of Curio, malia, bobby and Craster I am most suspicious of is malia. I think he doesn't really contribute much, the couple of missions he went on he didn't post at all between the mission being accepted and the result of the mission, (which would maybe suggest why there was possibly two spies and no sabotage, were they waiting to see what the other would do and not getting any clues, so just playing it safe?) and he organised the first mission which was sabotaged. Plus he didn't send himself on the first mission. If he was a goody, and sent himself on the first mission, he'd have had alright odds of picking two other goodies. I can't understand why a goody wouldn't send themself on the first mission.
I don't know about the second spy though, it could be any of the three of you to be honest. Although bobby is seducing me with his reason and logic, which is what curio did. Although curio has posted less since I said I trusted him, which is potentially dodgy. I'm tying myself in knots here.
My list would probably so far be
sdg
Slightly green
Saturnalian
my definite nots would be
kovacs
mr russell
malia
Because I think Slightly Green didn't pay enough attention to the posting of the other people going on a mission with him, which he would have done if he was a spy with a teammate on the mission
And I agree with the theory that at least one of Saturnalian and Grim... is good, and Grim... has been a bit too quite to make me feel confident of picking him.
I think other people should indicate who they would support, because I can't see how that would benefit the spies in any way but I think it could potentially benefit us and maybe even trip up the spies.