The Rev Owen wrote:
Grim... wrote:
Lave wrote:
At the end of the generation you would expect their to be only a handful of S ranked games across all platforms. A hall of fame kinda stuff.
Any current examples? Guitar Hero II, perhaps?
That's a good example, I think.
I'd probably give an S to, let's think...
OutRun 2006.
Resident Evil 4.
San Andreas.
Oblivion.
Dragon Quest VIII.
Halo.
Portal.
Disgaea.
Animal Crossing: Wild World.
Mario Galaxy.
To name some from the last couple of generations.
Hmm, it's always going to be subjective but I think it helps make it clear if I compare
*all* the titles I would give an S rank too, to *examples of those I would give an A or B too.
DSS rank: None to date.A rank: Kirby Canvas Curse
A rank: Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorny
A rank: New Super Mario Bros
A rank: 42 All Time Classics
A rank: Elite Beat Agents
B rank: Advance Wars DS
XboxS rank: Outrun 2006B rank: Psychonauts
360S rank: None to date.A rank: Omega 5
B rank: Dead Rising
GamecubeS rank: Prince of Persia: Sands of TimeS rank: LoZ: Wind WakerA rank: Resident Evil 4
A rank: Donkey Konga: Jungle Beat
WiiS rank: Super Mario GalaxyS rank: Wii SportsB rank: LoZ:Twilight Princess
A rank: Excite Truck
A rank: Endless Ocean
A rank: Sin and Punishment
GBAS rank: Rhythm TengokuS rank: Advance WarsS rank: Wario WareA rank: Metroid Fusion
A rank: Wario Ware Twisted
A rank: The Legend of Zelda Minish Cap.
B rank: Advance Wars 2
Clearly subjective, but that's idea anyway. What do people think? I was pleasantly surprised to see that the GBA wins out.