Be Excellent To Each Other

Yours.

I knew you were telling the truth, why do you think I attacked your logic and voted for you

Who the fuck is Gim...?

Oh, you're paying attention to what I'm saying now, eh? eh? eh?

Wait, so the ninja followed 2 people, who both did nothing, he decided to kill them anyway, and they were both mafia.

Pure dumb luck in other words!

Despite his subsequent unvote, Cras voted for Nick and that triggered the lynch.

Right?

Right.

When the final ballot is put through the slot,
The noose is tightened and the swing door drops,
The town celebrate and shout and cheer,
nikachu's true identity will lbecome clear.

He's the ninja.

Hah!

Well done town

I particularly liked Craster's bravado about the antidote.

Also, I'll update the rules in a bit, but Nick was basically telling the truth apart from his affiliation. He got to choose to side with the Mafia or Town during Night Three. He instead chose to side with nobody, thus giving him the mission to kill everyone.

Pure dumb luck indeed. But neither trooper or bobby can be trusted town is surely fucked now as there's at least 2 mafia left I presume.

Craster appears unaware of his death or the thread lock.

You said there would be side effects! Where were the side effects?!

Meh. I was already dead by the time I'd roleclaimed anyway. At least I got to kill Nickachu for being a massive belmer.

I was mostly bluffing in the roleclaim. The idea being that if I demonstrated an ability to protect myself infinitely, the mafia wouldn't bother targetting me. They wouldn't know that I was guessing about which scientist I was. Annoying that they got me the night before I did it

Yup. Also the fact that if I post in a locked thread it unlocks again. Sorry Curio!

I'd love to know what they were thinking after your role claim, given that they'd already targeted you.

I may have been a little bit pissed when I first claimed

There would have been side effects that were extremely beneficial to Town had you both not been selfish!

I wasn't so much "selfish" as "dead".

We figured the easiest way to see who was the "right" scientist would be to try it out on ourselves and see which one got the side effects.

Although our first communication went like this:

It was an investigative process. Grim... tested on himself, I tested on myself (but was roleblocked), I tested on myself again.

This game is hilarious!

<childish giggle>

This should be interesting. It's basically a talk-off now, as far as I can see there are no power town roles left.
The only way the town can win is by talking and not letting the days timeout, I wonder if that will make any difference to how much people post... (yeah, right)

"I can't see how we can bodge this up."

I can. The town has been hilariously flitting between one disaster and another all game. The only reason they stand a chance is because, essentially, another serial killer appeared.

man, if only someone had said that in their first post at the beginning of day one! If only they had an investagitive role! if only the town hadn't STUPIDLY KILLED THEM!

AND if you were still around? No difference.

No, you are right, the town wouldn't have listened to my words of knowledge and wisdom, so it wouldn't have made a difference. until too late. When everything I said came true. Again.

In all seriousness, the town have rarely,ever, done anything. they have always needed a power role to help them out/kill the mafia. Purely because they don't talk enough and tehre's only ever really one horse in the race for a lynch and then it times out. This stifles any form of discussion or things to spot about what is happening. no a comment on teh games design, more on not talking, I guess.

It helps if people like Gaz are less massively belmy.

Also that people don't really seem to go over previous days, think about why people were chosen to die and so on.

There's usually quite a bit to go on.

This game may be a bit more tricky to read due to the delayed death, but I think it works out in the towns favour overall. Indeed, it's probably one of the most innately town friendly rule sets I've seen.

But you were stuffed the moment you put in a role claim.

TFF for the mafia poisoner. It just seems too convenient that they ignored what I said then repeated what I said the next day.

They just aren't getting the entire poison thing, are they?

At least Zaphod appears to be some kind of sensible.

Hey! He is copying my bullshit logic calculation idea!

I have laughed very hard at Saturnalian's maths concluding that Zaphod a confirmed goodie must die. Hahaha!!

"I was also blocked..."

Yeah, at about this point, I'd be questioning anyone who claims this, given there's no one the mafia now need to block.

Why does Gaz still think there are no poisoners? Madness.

This is the most sensible thing said yet so far.

*shrug*

Fairly sure he's quite innocent as a result though.

Which doesn't leave all too terribly many people it can be. May well be the person that I originally suspected but then changed my mind about. Which would be annoying.

So Malc and TFF then?

Not the best day for Town, all said.

Have to lynch a bad person (preferably the poisoner) next day, or it is game over.

Who would y'all lynch?

Obviously, Mafia member need not answer!

I would lynch Malia.

Town is surely fucked now yes?

2 Mafia, 3 Town.

Still possible for a win or a draw for Town, but they have to get the next one right, which is a 50/50 call.

All 3 town have to agree, what are the chances of that

Reckon GazChap is a baddie, and the roleblocker didn't block anyone.

No-one would think there wasn't a poisoner now, would they?

If Malc's mafia, the town has a chance. If malc's not mafia, him voting for the wrong person is pretty much guaranteed, and the town loses

Also, I'd agree with Grim... - why roleblock when there's no non-mafia power roles left?