What did every do the past 3 days?
Day 1
Voted for mafia kill
zaphod79, Ian Fairies, Alberto, Slightly Green, Mr Russell, Trooper, Craster, DavPaz, GazChap, TheFireFaerie, sdg
Voted against mafia kill
Grim..., Bobbyaro, nickachu, Malc74
Didn't vote
malc, kovacsc, goddess jasmine, thevision, squirt
Day 2
Voted for a good guy kill
Ian Fairies, nickachu, Trooper, Alberto, Malc, DavPaz, Slightly Green, TheVision, KovacsC
Voted against a good guy kill
Grim..., sdg, Malc74
Didn't vote
craster, mr russell, bobbyaro, thefirefaerie, goddess jasmine
Day 3
Voted for a mafia kill
Craster, Grim..., TheVision, Trooper, Ian Fairies, DavPaz, Slightly Green, TheFireFaerie
Voted against a mafia kill
Goddess Jasmine, Nickachu, KovacsC
Didn't vote
malc, bobbyaro, malc74
So, to summarise the people left...
DavPaz - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Trooper - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Malc - didn't vote, killed good guy, didn't vote
Craster - killed mafia, didn't vote, killed mafia
Ian Fairies - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Bobbyaro - didn't kill mafia, didn't vote, didn't vote
TheFireFaerie - killed mafia, didn't vote, killed mafia
Malc74 - didn't kill mafia, didn't kill good guy, didn't vote
Nickachu - didn't kill mafia, killed good guy, didn't kill mafia
Grim... - didn't kill mafia, didn't kill good guy, killed mafia
TheVision - didn't vote, killed good guy, killed mafia
Let's crunch some numbers and give each action a number of points. I think it is fair to say actively doing something is worse than passively not doing something, so I think this scoring system works?
Killed mafia = +2
Killed good guy = -2
didn't kill mafia = -1
didn't kill good guy = +1
didn't vote = 0
Which gives us...
DavPaz - +4
Trooper - +4
Malc - -2
Craster - +4
Ian Fairies - +4
Bobbyaro - -1
TheFireFaerie - +4
Malc74 - 0
Nickachu - -4
Grim... - +2
TheVision - 0
And in order of evilness, from top to bottom...
Nickachu - -4
Malc - -2
Bobbyaro - -1
Malc74 - 0
TheVision - 0
Grim... - +2
DavPaz - +4
Trooper - +4
Craster - +4
Ian Fairies - +4
TheFireFaerie - +4
Are we so sure that Nickachu is good? If so, he is the
iest of any good guy out there
Giving him the benefit of the doubt for now...
[vote: malc]