Be Excellent To Each Other

Okay, this seems to be a pretty good round up.

We know that we have at least two town power roles still about (deputy and mayor) so that leaves four others to fit into those categories.

We need four votes for a lynch.

I'm wondering if it might be time for the Deputy to reveal themselves, the later they leave it now, the less chance they have to prove who they are. I'm inclined to agree that Trooper is likely the Mayor now.

What do others think?

If it is 3 reds left, then we lose, unless by some miracle they kill the red townie overnight.

If it is 2 red left, and the deputy has found them both, then he comes forward and we win.

oki, with a total lack of information I am happy to go with our Mayors choice today, so who are you plumping for Trooper? Unless our Deputy has some good information for us I think they should stay in te shadows until they can help by guiding us in the right direction.

ie. point us at a red if you know or jump in if trooper has us poinint at someone you know to be on our side.

So my vote is with Trooper, where does it go Mr Mayor?

You already know what the Mayor's choice would be. It would be me or Russell, as he's made clear above. So, the only reason you'd be saying this is because you want the mayor to start the voting, so you don't look suspicious. So you want either of me or Russell to leave, and you don't mind which.

That makes me think you're red, and based on GJ's post above, I think she's another.

[vote:Slightly Green]

wow

yes I know Trooper has his suspicions but since I am 'fairly sure' he is the Mayor (am pretty sure that someone else would have counter claimed by now if he wasn't), and since we don't have any more information to go on for now I would prefer to place my vote behind someone who I am 'fairly sure' is working for the town then to just take a random punt.

GJ hasn't rung any alarm bells for me this game so on my list she is sat in the green camp.

Your kneejerk reaction to a logical suggestion (Whats wrong with letting a known good guy make the choice, with the proviso that the investigator can jump in if a mistake is being made) makes me more suspicious of you, but I am going to wait to see what Trooper wants to do before casting any vote, especialy since only 4 votes are needed to evict.

We have plenty of time, i'd like to hear more from mr russ tonight

[vote:unvote]

Trooper's already said that the only people he's suspicious of are me and Russell. But you still want him to pull the trigger on the voting. Because you don't want to look like you're starting a bandwagon. Because you've got something to hide.

You didn't have a vote on anyhow did you? nvm

Yup the more people talk the better decision can be made

I did have a vote on

What is it with people not reading stuff this game

Eh? Why?

Bullshit.

we have 6 players left -

Mr Russell
Trooper
DavPaz
Slightly Green
Craster
Goddess Jasmine

of those 6 players I know I am green, I am 99% sure Trooper is green, and have a fairly strong feeling GJ is also green. So that leaves me with suspicions about Mr Russell, DavPaz and Craster.

If you look at my breakdown from my earlier post also then you can see that we have between 1 and 3 reds, more likely to be 2 but that is a guess.

I don't see how me saying that I am willing to follow Trooper makes me scum and no matter how much muck you throw will change that, I am sticking to my earlier point that following Troopers lead is the best option the town has at the moment unless we get more information somehow.

I have to disagree SG, simply because I don't think SG has anymore to go on than the rest of us.

I don't know what the answer is either though, hence my question about the best time for the deputy to reveal themselves and give us info.

Oops, that's supposed to say Trooper has no more to go on than the rest of us.

I don't have anything more, and have never claimed to have
It'll be as much a shot in the dark for me as anyone else, but if you do vote with me, at least you'll know it is a red taking you down a known wrong road.

Sorry you have lost me with this? please explain




I guess it depends entirly on what information our Deputy has for us, if they know who a red is then yes they should come forward, but it is possible they have no useful information for us at all. If thats the case then coming forward doesn't help does it? If I am looking at it wrong please let me know

it is *not* a red taking you down a known wrong road.

Jesus, what a typo

typo troop? Or am I failing to read english properly?

lol

Yes, I think that is what I was trying to say. I suppose that only the deputy knows if they have anything useful or not.

I suspect we only have one red left. Otherwise, going off other's numbers, we should have had a revolution by now? Right?

There could be two 'actives' left. More than that and theyd've piled on Trooper's vote for me and one. Having said that, SG didn't notice trooper's vote for me.

There could be red townies too, but as they don't know who the others are, there's no risk of a voting block.

So nothing from Mr Russ?

Not yet, not sure we will? Nothing to go on other than my original hunch.

[vote:mr russell]

C'mon Russ! Here's some motivation for ya!

[vote:Mr Russell]

I'm here finally.

My thoughts. I'm wary of the deputy revealing themselves. They're the only thing protecting the mayor from being killed overnight.

Normally it is my trick to ask a confirmed townie to provide a hunch for us to vote for, so I'm not that suss of SG.

I'd say so far my vote lies with Craster, so [vote:Craster].

Got to be honest, I'm leaning that way too.

I won't vote now to see what else develops, but I'll only have a quick pop back just after 11am.

Troop before I put a vote in are you sticking with Mr R? Just want some confirmation that your vote wasn't just a prod at him to get him talking.

Will vote when I get confirmation or it gets to 11 am

SG

I have no idea who is anybody, so i'm going to stick with my vote

Good enough for me

[vote:Mr Russell]

Hmm. Ok. Well I guess I made a rod for my own back there by asking the confirmed townie to vote.

It's ok, because the deputy can investigate again overnight, and provide a list of confirmed reds or confirmed greens tomorrow when the numbers are tight.

Mine was a prod.

[vote:Craster]

Lol. I have no idea

[vote:unvote]

eh? so your not going to follow Troopers vote?

I have to admit that Russ's reply does make me think that we might be voting for the wrong person, but I am still thinking it is better to go for a eviction and without information from the deputy Trooper is the best person to follow.

Assuming the deputy isn't killed overnight.

I really think now is the time for the deputy to speak up, if they have anything to share, we are most likely going to be another townie down overnight and onto an almost certain loss, or a deputy down overnight, and a certain loss.

I'm inclined to agree. Even if they don't know who any of the bad guys are, even being able to identify 1 good guy would put us in a good position.

[vote:unvote]

oki I am not convinced this is a great idea but since it seems to be the concensus that I should step into the light, I shall.

I am the Deputy (ironicly MaliA almost got the Sheriff and Deputy evicted...)

The main reason I haven't jumpped forward with a role claim before now is I have very little useful information as you shall see below

Night 1 - Investigated Grim... - Magenta

Night 2 - Investigated KovacsC - Red

Night 3 - Investigated Malc - Green

Night 4 - Investigated Bobby - Green

Night 5 - Investigated GJ - Green

As you can see the only person still alive that has been investigated is GJ who is Green, take into account no one has counter claimed againt Trooper and we know that 3 of the 6 people are good.

So we look like -

Trooper - Mayor? Unconfirmed but very unlikely to be a hoax**
Goddess Jasmine
Slightly Green

Mr Russell
DavPaz
Craster

**If Trooper isn't the mayor then the real mayor needs to be run out of town.

Now I have come forward I don't see myself surviving the night, so this is all the information you will get from the Inspector Cluso-esk policing force you have been given sorry folks. I was hoping to survive tonight and have some useful information on the morrow, but it is unlikly as everone other than GJ that I have investigated seems to die straight away, I was wondering if i was a hidden serial killer at one point.

As I said in my analysis previously I hope we only have one red left but it may be two....

I have the feeling that Craster is Red, but that is just a hunch, no real foundation.

Hmm... I could vote for Craster I suppose.

well to be fair MrPaz I am bouncing between Craster yourself and Mr Russ for being red, less so with Mr Russ now.

So GJ, Troop who do we vote for? Craster or DavPaz (or even Mr R if you have a suspicion )?

If the 3 of us make sure to stick together then we have a 33% or 66% chance of hitting a red, depending on how many of them are left.

I will be killed off tonight and you guys will get another shot tomorrow if we miss or they have 2.

Aww, it's not nice to be trusted.

I guess it's safe to say that Trooper is the mayor as no-one has counter claimed.

Not nice to *not* be trusted.

LOLLIPOPS

Well, being as I thought craster might have been the cop, so was wary of voting for him even though he was pinging my radar over the rules stuff, and sg is happier with russ for whatver reason, I'm going to go with

[vote:craster]

I know Dav, but this game does make you paranoid

Oki, I will go for that then

[vote:craster]

Aye, alriight then.

[vote:craster]

And I am about to get killed I guess