Be Excellent To Each Other

Hmmm... lets see if anyone votes for you then

So, you don't like quiet people, eh? Like our dear departed Deputy? He was quiet, and bam, dead. Now you stand before me advocating killing quiet people.

Yes, i'm advocating voting for quiet people, as they are no help to the group. Do you disagree?

Who did you contact and target?

So you admit to targeting MaliA on night one?

Bobby and Mr Russel, are you two working together?

Very similar questions.

How could we possibly be? I contacted krazywookie and DavPaz. As mentioned. You?

Bobby could have contacted you. As well you know.

I'm sorry are you talking to me, as that doesn't make any sense.

I've already said who I targeted and contacted, I said that yesterday and i've said today.

I'm talking about voting for people who are being quiet, no more, no less. The fact that you seem to be trying to make that into more than it is says more about you than it does about me, I think.

Ahem. Oh. Oh yeah.

Well, you only have my word as to the fact that I received no messages.

Kovacs are you working with Trooper, you seem to be defending him?

Also Trooper, yes I am asking you, I fail to see why:
1) Voting for quiet people helps us in the slightest
2) you, as someone who appears to dislike quiet people, wouldn't target a quiet person in the hope you would kill them!

It's impossible to know what we are up against as we have no role call of who might be in this facility from Boobies.

Some of those who have not yet woken may be feigning sleep still, to cover the fact that they rise early enough to have their roles confirmed by Boobies? That's one reason to be suspicious of those who have not yet spoken.

I'm at a bit of a loss myself as my attempts to contact and target have come to nothing, so I'm still looking for more subtle nuances of people's behaviour, and I think that as previous days have been quite short that there is a possibility that people have not yet blinked awake are perhaps very much awake and laying low after finding things out? May not be the case, but worth considering, do you think?

Grim... did you get your role confirmed?

I am not working with Trooper, but I agree that quiet people kills the game...

We all remember that game, that the mod stopped as it was toooooo boring.

So Bobby unless you want that so you can pick folks off in the night!

1) because the only way for the town to win is if people share information. The only way to share information is to speak up and be heard.
2) why would I assume that I have a kill role, the odds are massively against that. Why do you assume I would have a kill role? A slip of the tongue because you have one maybe?

To me, this just seems to be an attack on me based on trying to twist an argument that is pretty much agreed to be a good argument.
Thought that I was close to being lynched yesterday and see me as an easy target to try and get rid of today did you? Lets get a bandwagon going based on a spurious argument, the holes in the argument you hope will be overlooked in a quick lynch?

[vote: bobbyaro]

So what you are saying is, "Me and Trooper are talking loads so don't kill us, look we are talking, anyone who speaks German can't be bad!"

And a reactionary vote! Brilliant!

and another vote, with good justification, that is passed off as reactionary to try and invalidate it. Brilliant!

[vote:applepieofdestiny]

Not right now.

I think I know my role, and believe that I am good. My targets and contacts however have no effect, so I'm not in control of it. I haven't confirmed my role as I only have one bite of the cherry at getting it right (and think I've missed the boat anyway).

Raising my head above the parapet now is risky for me, I admit. I was not under suspicion but have now added murk to the world and so that may change. Plus any bad guys may consider me to be a risk.

However, there will be only one kill overnight.

Actually just read this through, this makes no sense at all.

"A slip of the tongue" What? I accused you of killing someone one, that is a really lame attempt at a turn around.

"the only way for the town to win is to share info" But you aren't doing so nor letting that happen, you want to kill people before they can talk.

And furthermore, "easy to get rid of you today..." If I had wanted rid of you yesterday, I could have voted for you.

Logical fallacy and you know it.

"Not speaking = bad" is not equivalent to "speaking = good".

A lips of the tongue, you assumed I would think I had a killing role, why would you assume that?

Voting for quiet people will likely get them to speak up and increase the talking. You'll also note that I advocated not voting for the quiet ones until they had the opportunity to speak.

You didn't vote for me yesterday, I wonder what changed overnight to put you on the attack against me today? Seems an abrupt shift, like you say, you could have lynched me yesterday.

I see Trooper is doing exactly the same today as he was yesterday. The only constant in this sea of variables! I see no reason not to vote for him again today.

[Vote:Trooper]

If you mean talking, stimulating discussion, putting out theories and acting upon them, then yes. I'm doing exactly the same as yesterday and make no apology for it.

Morning all, sorry im up so late, I always sleep in this long.

So my contact was target was Grim... and my contact was malc. nothing happened so im guessing that im pretty unimportant here but I got up too late to contact Boobies.

I think we probably only have one killer left so those displaying inconsistant arguments are the next lynch target by my logic.

trooper: 1 (myp)
applepieofdestiny: 1 (krazywookie)
bobbyaro: 1 (Trooper)
craster: 1 (Mr Russell)

Not voted: 13 (craster, runcle, mimi, goddess jasmine, kovacsc, mr dom, thevision, bobbyaro, grim..., applepieofdestiny, malc, joans, alarm)

With 17 players alive, 9 votes are required for a lynch, and 9 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/work.php

I'm up for some of this

[vote:trooper]

Nope.

And yet you were up and about early.

Maybe he guessed wrong?

Malc

So he could give us info about what he guessed.

I was indeed, but unfortunately I didn't make my guess in time.

So there are still people about who have had their guesses confirmed (wrongly or rightly) and are yet to speak up.

I guessed but got a message back saying I was too late, but that was expected as I didn't wake up till after the day had be running for two hours!

I guessed Doctor - because I figured that was the hardest role to figure out whether you had it or not - and was told I was wrong.

Also, do you seriously expect someone to wave their hand in the air and say "I asked if I was <townie power role X>, and Boobies said I was correct!"?

Wierd... I was up after you and I got a reply. We're you slacking as you already knew you had a killing role?

Craster & Myp claim to have been told 'no' - both guessing at doctor/roleblocker.
Not sure why they would guess that.
I guessed at vanilla townie as I knew I wasn't killing or contacting, so figured I should find out if I was a real nobody, or there was some secret I could discover later if only I contacted the right person type thing.

GJ was also an early riser, so I can only guess that she and 1 other mystery person got their requests in and are keeping schtum for some reason...

I've already surmised from the last two nights that my role has no visible effect on people, and that I'm not getting any information as a result of anything I do overnight. I could have been protecting people each night (Doctor), so I asked if that was the case. It was not.

I guessed at roleblocker.

No, I was slacking because I was on a train and didn't read the first post properly for a while that gas messes with my head, and it took a while for me to think of what to ask.


I guessed at roleblocker, too, due to the 'invisibility' of the role.

I was up too early, as I was out before the day started. I attempted to target and contact the same people I did on the first night, both of them are still alive.

Nothing happened to the people I contacted/targeted either.. Same as the first two nights.

I've been sitting back, taking all your arguments in today and I'm still none the wiser of who to go for. Someone knows more than they're letting on but they're not exactly going to out themselves are they?

The problem is, even if one of the goodies did know more than they're letting on (and it's quite possible that they don't) they would be afeared to say anything because, with no-one to protect them (or, at least, no-one that knows they can protect them) they would quickly be dead.

Have you been playing for three nights, then? Interesting...

Right then, sorry I've only just woken up, I obviously needed my sleep.

I did get in to contact boobies this morning, all I know is that I am not a mafia goon.

I'm not going to say who I've targeted the last two nights and I don't think anybody else should either. If we have a group, lets call them a 'Mafia' every time one of use tells them that we contacted them and it didn't work it gives them a better idea for who to target the next night.

I've had a bit of a think about what people have said today, but it all just looks like bickering really.

Well yes but there isn't much to go on is there?

Nope.

So, is the plan to lynch someone tonight and hope that we get a bad guy?

Isn't that pretty much always the plan?