Be Excellent To Each Other

So - 'quoting' stuff from the GM, fake or otherwise. Permissible or not?

Either way, how should Rule 5 be reworded?

I don't think in this case, I did anything that I ouldn't have done standing in a village square. I basically just repeated my 'role', which turned out to be fake, which unkown to me was almost a carbon copy of a secret hidden role in the game that I wasn't aware of.
We have decid what it is about my roleclaim makes people feel it is unfair to decide where to to draw the line. Would it have been better if I had just said I'm a spy? because if I was really a spy, I'd hav had more info than that. So should I have given my role description and night actions etc? If so, was it just a matter of copying Troopers formatting? because again, I really don't think that's an issue. Any player in the game could have done that, I was making it all up not using info that only some players were privvy to.
If I had wanted to roleclaim as a Swiss, I could have copied the text and formatting from the rules thread, although that would be unecessary because everyone could see it anyay so I don't see why it matters for a fake claim. The fact is, people saw through it (damn me for choosing Bobby!) so it proves that it was an invincible strategy. I don't think it's a big deal.

How kind you are to everyone else

I refuse to compliment you in mafia game because you are my nemesisises and so to compliment you is to give you power.

Grim... was pretty belming, so I don't know what he is crowing about Roleclaiming as a german, with a team mate who is about to go on holiday, and then picking a night action that basically got him killed

I was rather shocked by the first mod kill since Craster jumped into a volcano some time in 2009. Stupid Bobby.

Grim... could play a cop, with the role of protecting the town, and belmingly kill an innocent every single night, but on the last day expose me as a baddy. Seriously. Nemesis.

He was your teammate! Maybe you could have talked to each other

I think he was busy...

I'd get you lynched, too

Have we ever been on the same side?

[edit]Not counting townies, of course. I haven't been a normal townie for aaaaaaaages

I think we might have been, once. I can't really remember though.

your attempt to play without looking at the rules would have been hilarious for this game, as pretty much everyone had a role!

I did until day four, then Bobby wasn't around to tell me if we liked the person we investigated or not.