Be Excellent To Each Other

Ace. Except I have someone who can corroborate my story (if needed. Don't come forward yet, Robin).

See you later, evil-face!

Woah woah woah wtf!

*reads back hastily*

If he is the joker and your innocent then we loose nothing from him being protected tonight as he will be lynched asap on the morrow, so he will pop off one more person if he is the joker if he isn't and is a good power roll and he gets offed we are in a much worse position

Hey, I'm happy to wait for the real Batman to show up and prove you wrong (or, more realistically, the real Robin).

I'm merely a hero.

But we'd kill him tomorrow.

No offence, but if you're only an innocent bystander, then I'm willing risk you on Russ's word and if you are a goodie, we lynch Russ tomorrow.

Either way, we should end tomorrow (if not today) with only 2 baddies to find.

THis.


More later. Let's not fast-lynch anyone, pls.

And, if he's Joker and protected tonight, he's effectively roleblocked.

Sorry sorry, I have been far too quite this game I know but if we can keep the lynching to a minimum I will definitly be around a little later on to give more input.

No, let's lynch Curiosity. If we need any more input it's for who you want me to investigate.

SuperScum 2 : Day 3

VOTE UPDATE

mr russell: 1 (Curiosity)
gazchap: 1 (kalmar)
curiosity: 5 (Mr Russell, Slightly Green, flis, Grim..., KovacsC)

Not voted: 7 (alarm, gazchap, goddess jasmine, gospvg, joans, jon.j, sinister agent)

With 14 players alive, 8 votes are required for a lynch, and 11 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

Stop trying to push for a rushed lynch before someone comes along able to disprove your roleclaim!!!

If we lynch today will we get another day started? With Trooper going away I mean.

Well I hope so, as he's not away til tomorrow

[vote: unvote]

Although I was suspicious of curio myself I'm not going to jump on the bandwagon until I've read a bit more.
There is a chance this is an audacious bluff, and those only work if people rush into it without giving time for rebuttals or thinking it through.

Personally i would like Gos or GJ investigated, but i am not sure we should discuss who you investigate if you are the Batfink as if we reach a consensus on someone and that person is the super villain then they will try to kill you knowing they will hit you with a effective role-block, since the order is - Roleblocks - Protecting - Investigating - Arresting - Kryptonite - Kill

If you are whom you suggest then it is better for you to investigate at random and hope that they don't try to off youas they need to hit their primary win conditions which are Kill superman or Kill everyone

I think that is right anyhow

I totally agree in taking our time with the lynch but I don't see the need to have Mr Russell not confirm which investigation role he is.

He has, he claims to be batfink

There really is not any need to rush things.

Yeah, I already claimed as the world's greatest detective, ie Batman.

I investigated Curiosity and he returned the win condition KILL SUPERMAN.

I probably got a bit excited here and should have saved this another night maybe, but fuck it, he's a baddie.

Sounds pretty convincing!

I wonder why he's been out to get GazChap?

Not sure. Unless he was just picking on a genuinely quiet person to divert suspicion. It's one tactic we always mention about lynching the quiet ones, so he probably thought it was a safe thing to do.

I'm popping to the shops, don't lynch anyone while I'm gone!

[vote: jon.j]

[vote:curiosity]

I picked Gaz because he:

A) Said nothing on Day Two (neatly putting a large hole in Mr Russ's original accusation of me)
b) Got imprisoned on the same night that there was one fewer kill than possible.

All of my logic was genuine.

And I do wish one half of the dynamic duo would hurry up and call Russ's bluff.

I'm only human, not a super character, so I can't be 'roleblocked' by a failed kill on me from any of the bad guys. As long as I get protected I can investigate as long as we please.

Correct me if I'm wrong, please.

Point A I was using as fake logic to say why I was pushing for you, but then I got excited and roleclaimed anyway, so forget that point. I suspected you as being evil because of that point, which I mentioned in my investigation PM to Trooper, so yah boo sucks to you.

Is there anyone who has not yet posted who could conceivably be Batman or Robin and wishes to call my bluff?

Bueller?

I could protect myself of course, but then I just become a normal person, as I waste my opportunity to investigate.

You quite simply could not have said that, as last night I was protected from investigation by Superman.

You're digging yourself a great big hole, Joker!

Awesomely desperate.

You have no idea how big the grin on my face is right now.

Joker roleclaim?

Oh dude, the last person who said that was DavPaz, and he am superdead as well.

Interesting.

Assuming that Russ is telling the truth, Curio's assertion that Superman protected him should invite a call-out from Superman if it's false.

If we assume that Curio's telling the truth, Russ's roleclaim should invite a call-out from one of the real dynamic duo.

So far, neither.

Could be that Russ knows who Superman is and is trying to get a lynch going?

Could be that Curio knows he's for the chop and is trying to save his Kill-Superman-Win-Condition neck?

Who knows. Tune in next time, same bat-time, same bat-cha... <urk>

So, you roleclaim as Joker and are now threatening me that I'll die for saying you're The Joker?

C'mon people! He's scum! Vote Mr Russell!

Um, are you saying that if I'm protected I can't investigate? Because otherwise I think I have it read pretty well. Someone protects me, and if either of the remaining two bad guys (after Curio swings today) try to kill me, I will not die. I will instead get to carry out my investigation, and everything becomes peachy.

1. People that wanted me to talk. Here I am, I have nothing to say though, except "hey, what's that in the sky?" etc.
2. [vote:curiosity] seriously people, I know it's metadata, but he's the biggest bluffer/liar ever in these games.
3. I probably won't be around much until tomorrow afternoon/night, but I'll drop in if I can.

Yes, but we don't want this, as one other baddie shares his win condition. Therefore if Superman reveals himself the other baddie can kill him, and Curio still gets his win condition despite being deaded all over.

I'm just ignoring the rules to be on the safe side. Curio is looking pretty dodgy though

After all of this is done, please note that there may still be henchmen out there. We can't rely on DavPaz's belming slip to say that they're all now gone.

Hi, can I count on your vote, or are we still waiting for someone to come along and claim to be batman or robin?

Stop trying to rush a lynch, Russ.

Just because you're evil!

Yes, I think you can.

[vote: Curiosity]

Dude, I can't wait to discuss this with you after the game.

Oh, and if we get a lynch before six then I get to walk home with a skip in my step!

BECAUSE YOU ARE THE JOKER.

People, do not trust this liar and scoundrel.

Superman, you KNOW he's lying. Do not protect him.

Batman, you KNOW he's lying. Do not protect him.

They only have to protect me after you're dead and proved to be a big bluffy liar.

OK. If I were the joker, then sadly that doesn't even add up as I investigated both nights, and there has been 1 joker kill. Therefore even with the joker's investigate ability I would not have been able to make that kill.

This falls down on the following point: I have not yet revealed who I investigated on night one. Good job the boy wonder can back me up if I need to prove THAT point.

Boom!

That's simply a bluff, and a poor one at that.

You have not investigated twice. The other one is a completely made-up investigation, and you're relying on getting enough votes to lynch me before anyone can step up to stop you.