LazyScum2 Day 1

Bobbyaro · **Joined:** 18th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 11843

That post! :DD

TheFireFaerie · **Joined:** 1st Jul, 2012 **Posts:** 1609

Saturnalian wrote:

If Mr Dave was Robert and Robert was bad then an investigation might have a false negative. Or something.

*head explodes*

TheFireFaerie · **Joined:** 1st Jul, 2012 **Posts:** 1609

So. Mr Dave ISN'T Mr Dave. Possibly. At this point would the real Mr Dave (please stand up, please stand up) be a valuable reveal or is it too early? The Doctor could protect him as he doesn't have to wait until night time to investigate so we'd get the results before a possible kill. But then he might get killed. And at this stage it's fairly pot luck so might not be all that helpful.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

There's no indication we have a doctor so Mr Dave (no, the other one) roleclaiming is probably not worthwhile unless he already has useful info.

Having said that, the argument for a mass roleclaim still applies like it did last time - there's no roles with multiple people, so a valid idea. Might be a bit against the spirit though

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

Oh wait, it totally doesn't apply. We'd know who everyone is, but not what their win conditions are - so useless.

myp · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 16:03

Mr Dave wrote:

Assuming, of course, that Mr Dave is a pro-town kinda guy. Which he ought to be in order to "be" Mr Dave

This line of thinking is fallacious considering the GM has chosen everyone's win conditions, not the players. We can't assume Mr Dave is good or otherwise.

TheFireFaerie · **Joined:** 1st Jul, 2012 **Posts:** 1609

Cras wrote:

There's no indication we have a doctor so Mr Dave (no, the other one) roleclaiming is probably not worthwhile unless he already has useful info.

Having said that, the argument for a mass roleclaim still applies like it did last time - there's no roles with multiple people, so a valid idea. Might be a bit against the spirit though

Er...

Character name: The Doctor
Description: renegade Time Lord from the planet Gallifrey
Night power (if any): can choose to protect someone overnight.

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 16:19

Future Warrior wrote:

Mr Dave wrote:

Assuming, of course, that Mr Dave is a pro-town kinda guy. Which he ought to be in order to "be" Mr Dave

This line of thinking is fallacious considering the GM has chosen everyone's win conditions, not the players. We can't assume Mr Dave is good or otherwise.

Well, yeah. Let's break down what I said -

Piece of information: Mr Dave Might not be good despite detectiving - "Assuming, of course, that Mr Dave is a pro-town kinda guy"
Subsequent reiteration that I'm a good guy, and much prefer "be"ing them: "Which he ought to be in order to "be" Mr Dave"

Although I believe there was an opportunity to rewrite should one be able to kill.

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 16:21

TheFireFaerie wrote:

Cras wrote:

There's no indication we have a doctor so Mr Dave (no, the other one) roleclaiming is probably not worthwhile unless he already has useful info.

Er...

Character name: The Doctor
Description: renegade Time Lord from the planet Gallifrey
Night power (if any): can choose to protect someone overnight.

"We" may not be able to include the Doctor among our numbers. He may be a bad-un, and disinterested in protecting somone who isn't his kin.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

This is where I totally pretend that what Mr Dave (no, not that one) said is what I meant, and I didn't gloss over the fact that The Doctor was, in fact, cunningly, a doctor.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

Oh, should Billy Fact-check-o-matic want something assertive to go on, as I have mostly posted opinion so far, here you go:

I am not a bad guy.

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 16:29

Define: Bad guy.

TheFireFaerie · **Joined:** 1st Jul, 2012 **Posts:** 1609

Cras wrote:

This is where I totally pretend that what Mr Dave (no, not that one) said is what I meant, and I didn't gloss over the fact that The Doctor was, in fact, cunningly, a doctor.

Conveniently forgetting that there's a potential (because yeah, he might be a bad dude) save role out there?

Tsk.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

Mr Dave wrote:

Define: Bad guy.

OK - I want the town to win.

zaphod79 · **Joined:** 16th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 14489

So a few thoughts :

The cult may have multiple ways of spreading and because they are around I think we really should be trying to do something on day 1
The fact that some people can only use their ability on people once is an issue because its likely that their goals will change over the game

I would think that Gaz's information is correct , and I'd say the two neutral are the cult + some type of SK

Mr Dave's role (not the real Mr Dave the characters) makes my head hurt.

The Bin role makes me smile :-)

Curiosity · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 17:31

Bin is the new Nightcunt.

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 17:39

zaphod79 wrote:

Mr Dave's role (not the real Mr Dave the characters) makes my head hurt.

Mr Daves role hurts my head too.

I am finding it amusing though.

Curiosity · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 17:46

I suspect that there would be a Mafia kill role, just not a mentioned one. We'll find out soon enough, no doubt.

Cruise is probably culty, though it might actually be a joke and he isn't, which would be amusing. Would be ace if he was an incompetent cult leader who couldn't recruit anyone.No idea who else would be neutral. Possibly the bin.

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 18:23

Curiosity wrote:

I suspect that there would be a Mafia kill role, just not a mentioned one. We'll find out soon enough, no doubt.

Cruise is probably culty, though it might actually be a joke and he isn't, which would be amusing. Would be ace if he was an incompetent cult leader who couldn't recruit anyone.

I don't think that someone would write an incompetent cult leader role for themselves, somehow.

I'd mainly be looking at the people lacking an obvious night role... Hollis, Fraudster, Cedrick for killing peoples.
But of course, no idea who they actually are. It's still a potshoot at the moment, bar the people with day actions.

Curiosity · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 18:30

Maybe, but would you be allowed to write yourself an actual cult leader?

It's a mystery!

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 18:43

Curiosity wrote:

Maybe, but would you be allowed to write yourself an actual cult leader?

It's a mystery!

Would you write yourself a cult leader role without first checking you could? If it were me, I'd check it was a valid role before submitting it.

I suppose it could be a cult without win condition change. Something like the masons where they can chat amongst themselves. And Praise Elrond.

Or a bona-fide cult, but again the lack of a cult condition and explicit denial make me a little doubtful.

Goddess Jasmine · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 19:11

zaphod79 wrote:

So a few thoughts :

The cult may have multiple ways of spreading and because they are around I think we really should be trying to do something on day 1
The fact that some people can only use their ability on people once is an issue because its likely that their goals will change over the game

I would think that Gaz's information is correct , and I'd say the two neutral are the cult + some type of SK

Mr Dave's role (not the real Mr Dave the characters) makes my head hurt.

The Bin role makes me smile :-)

I agree with much of this. There are 12 of us, so it's important to consider how many days (or lynches) we might have to win (assuming one Mafia killer, one SK and a cult). There is the potential to lose three town tonight.

Satsuma · **Joined:** 20th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 14356

Day 1 is always a crap shoot anyway.

I heard that in a film once. I'm assuming that I'm using it correctly.

We should get that "Who are the quiet ones" thing in here to assist. The quiet ones are probably afraid of the 8 post count thing and therefore bad uns.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

If there's a cult, Gazchap is a lying bumface.

myp · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 20:22

Cras wrote:

If there's a cult, Gazchap is a lying bumface.

Elaborate.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

He said that he knew the alignments in the game, and that there were three maf and two neutral.

It would be a super-bold early lie, so I'm inclined to believe there's no cult.

myp · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 20:50

Cras wrote:

He said that he knew the alignments in the game, and that there were three maf and two neutral.

It would be a super-bold early lie, so I'm inclined to believe there's no cult.

Could cult not be neutral, as in not mafia or town?

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 21:11

Future Warrior wrote:

Cras wrote:

He said that he knew the alignments in the game, and that there were three maf and two neutral.

It would be a super-bold early lie, so I'm inclined to believe there's no cult.

Could cult not be neutral, as in not mafia or town?

Neutral generally means not associated with any group. Which wouldn't be the case for a cult. Which is decidedly groupie.

Goddess Jasmine · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 21:14

Mr Dave wrote:

Future Warrior wrote:

Cras wrote:

He said that he knew the alignments in the game, and that there were three maf and two neutral.

It would be a super-bold early lie, so I'm inclined to believe there's no cult.

Could cult not be neutral, as in not mafia or town?

Neutral generally means not associated with any group. Which wouldn't be the case for a cult. Which is decidedly groupie.

Surely there needs to be more than one for there to be a group though? The cult leader could be hit on night one before getting chance to recruit, so never really part of a group.

Curiosity · **Posted:** Mon Jan 12, 2015 22:03

If I was a cult leader I would totes be targeting Gaz tonight

Bobbyaro · **Joined:** 18th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 11843

Didn't the Mafia fail to provide themselves with a kill role last time?

Satsuma · **Joined:** 20th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 14356

Curiosity wrote:

If I was a cult leader I would totes be targeting Gaz tonight

You're beng super unhelpful at the minute. What's the point here? To push the cult to target Gazchao making a helpful role to be counter-town? To force Gaz to role claim? Oh wait he did!' And no no one is disputing it so it's probably real.

Either you've got a death wish or something else. Sounds very untown.

Curiosity · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 1:03

It was done for multiple reasons. Amongst which foremost are:

1) To remind the Town that even if Gaz is telling the truth now, he may be lying very soon
2) If there is a cult leader there will likely be people he cannot recruit. If Gaz, with all his powers, is one, it could draw a failed convert action. Alternatively, he could recruit Gaz; this is still not all bad as any anti-Mafia info gleaned would be truthfully passed on. Obviously though we would need to kill him at a later date.

Of course, he could also be Mafia for all we know.

Grim... · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 10:38

Trooper wrote:

Oh, and Mr Dave (not that Mr Dave) can count his own fucking posts, so let me know when someone reaches 8 and you want to investigate

This should help: http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/quiet.php

Hi, everybody! Sorry I'm late.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

This says that Grim... is really quiet!!

Grim... · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 10:49

Well, I am. Right now.

Good work on fucking Gazchap up, btw.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

YEAH!

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

I'm going to go ahead and say there's little point doing any lynching today. We have no clue which roles correlate to win conditions so very little to go on, and with every role being a potential power role, much to lose.

[vote:nolynch]

Curiosity · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 11:43

[vote:cras]

:DD

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

Mr Dave · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 12:02

Curiosity wrote:

[vote:cras]

:DD

I wouldn't say his behaviour exactly screams bad guy.

zaphod79 · **Joined:** 16th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 14489

Cras wrote:

I'm going to go ahead and say there's little point doing any lynching today. We have no clue which roles correlate to win conditions so very little to go on, and with every role being a potential power role, much to lose.

[vote:nolynch]

Err , the cult ?

If what has been posted before is correct and we have a cult today is your 1 in 11 chance of stopping it before it has started

Curiosity · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 12:13

Mr Dave wrote:

Curiosity wrote:

[vote:cras]

:DD

I wouldn't say his behaviour exactly screams bad guy.

He wants to let the bad guys kill us all and us not to do the only thing that we can; press people for info and hope we get lucky.

Even if we're not lynching we should try something. we could feasibly start tomorrow with a growing cult and two more dead townies (Mafia and SK/Vig), plus bugger all info.

TheFireFaerie · **Joined:** 1st Jul, 2012 **Posts:** 1609

zaphod79 wrote:

Cras wrote:

I'm going to go ahead and say there's little point doing any lynching today. We have no clue which roles correlate to win conditions so very little to go on, and with every role being a potential power role, much to lose.

[vote:nolynch]

Err , the cult ?

If what has been posted before is correct and we have a cult today is your 1 in 11 chance of stopping it before it has started

I'm with this - as always, the no lynch is a pointless waste of a day when we could potentially hit bad / cult / SK even if only by chance. They're going to go for it, so I say so do we.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

So vote for Gazchap then. If there's a cult, he's a liar. If there isn't, there's no point lynching anyone.

myp · **Posted:** Tue Jan 13, 2015 12:16

[vote: cras]

Sorry, but you've made some very suss posts. You're either feigning stupidity for nefarious reasons, or you're not concentrating. Either way, we can probably do without you and would be good to get some kind of info today.

Bobbyaro · **Joined:** 18th Apr, 2008 **Posts:** 11843

Ooooh, a new debate!

Helpful I know, but Zaphod, if you want to vote for someone, you are going to have to convince people. We have nothing to go off, so it is completely random, who should we vote for? Note, it isn't me.

Also, if the sides were handed out by trooper, wouldn't cult count as a side, so if it is random, then* there is a chance that Tom Cruise isn't the cult leader, and there may not even be a cult, even if Tom wants to be a cult leader.

*almost certainly not random.

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

This from you, after I had to point out Gazchap's earlier post to you where he said there is no cult?

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

Oops - my last was at Myp

Cras · **Joined:** 30th Mar, 2008 **Posts:** 49232

Quoting this because people appear to be ignoring it totally.

GazChap wrote:

This is possibly going to get me killed, so if The Doctor wants to protect me overnight, then that's fine with me. I figure this is a pretty good thing for the town to know at this point as day 1 is traditionally the one with no info.

I'm Psychic Steve. My allegiance is Town. I can investigate people overnight (once only per person though) and find out their faction.

However, my psychic abilities don't stop there. At the start of each day, I think really hard about the town and I can find out how many of each faction there are - except for my own faction.

My strong thoughts and crystal balls have told me that there are three Mafia and two neutrals. It's strongly hinted of course that Tom Cruise is a cult leader - if I survive this night I'll be able to find out if he's been recruiting.

Either GazChap is lying scum, or there is no cult.

Be Excellent To Each Other

LazyScum2 Day 1

Who is online