Be Excellent To Each Other

DOUBLE fair point! Not knowing DACs win conditions == BADGUY!
[vote: Kalmar]
Im pretty sure Runcle is a happy hippy DAC too, and I havent seen Curio do anything to suggest he is, and DavPaz knows em too, so passes this little test.

But still.. Kalmar.. schoolboy error...

Unless he's a marine.

Mr Dom, it's doubtful that Kalmar would get lynched today, so your vote might be better used on Curio to help turn up the heat a little?

Who would you prefer to spend the night with: A slobbering non speaking, killing machine, or an Alien?

I would have thought that since most people have voted already today (which is slightly unusual for day one) then the bad guys votes would have been cast. I would doubt there would eb enough bad guys left to suddenly place an unused vote onto a player they know not to be on their team. I would also doubt that ever bad guy would vote so as the last few votes for an innocent person was by them.
I also find it slightly odd that would you suggest otherwise since I think all my assumptions stated above are probably shared by most people present.

Even if they hadn't voted yet, it'd be an insane bad (or good) team that block voted on day 1.

Hmmm, rather keen aren't you? Its not 100% vital to vote on the first day in my opinion.

VOTE UPDATE

kalmar: 1 (Mr Dom)
craster: 2 (Mr Dave, Bobbyaro)
curiosity: 6 (DavPaz, Runcle, kalmar, Goddess Jasmine, superdupergill, GazChap)
runcle: 7 (Grim..., Curiosity, Terimahkaseh, zaphod79, Craster, Morte, The Rev Owen)

Not voted: 3 (cpt_droman, joans, mr russell)

With 19 players alive, 10 votes are required for a lynch, and 14 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

That's an opinion I usually defend strongly on day one but in this instance, when we have two different enemy factions and one of them can only get stronger I think it is important that we get as much info as possibe early in the game, and having two people up for the vote with one subsequently going is the best way for us to get that info.

Keen to information gather yes. I have already said I will retract my vote if need be, this isn't about someone getting lynched (I don't believe Curio will at this point anyway), but pressure on people does give us info.

Weren't we on 8 and 7 a short while ago? What happened? I'm sure I read that...

Mmm. A list: Mr Dom, Kalmar, Gazchap, DavPaz, Zaphod.

Make of that what you will, although I'd suggest making one of your own.

And I thought Runcle was on nine before that too, I'd just put it down to me being an idiot though. Can someone go back and recount? I need to erm, have a nap now. I'll wake up around 4ish I reckon.

I'm worried about the safety of this crash damaged colony, especially as night falls pretty hard around here.

Some wildcatters went out to the Ilium range on Company orders and never came back. I didn't ask why they were sent there because it takes two weeks to get an answer out here and the answer's always 'don't ask.' Nice couple, too.

Mr Dom voted kalmar so that took one vote away from on of them, what happened to the other vote-am I being really thick here?

I saw it peak at 8 and 6.

Unfortunately not, I'm just suffering from "rule fatique" a bit and hadn't bothered to think through the current ones.

It is every man for himself. Given that, nobody good should be sacrificing themselves.

When I suggested someone voting to level them out, Craster replied with the comment about it being bad if they were both on 8 and 8. So at that point they were on 8 and 7. Mr Dom changed his vote to kalmar which reduces one total by one vote but i cant see where the other reduction came from. Just curious in case I have missed any strange voting behaviour!

Okay!

Cats, tractors, pies, Sister Wendy and the central limit theorem.

Check that,



Mr Dom, Kalmar, Gazchap, DavPaz, Zaphod, Mr Russ.

No, at that point they were on 8 and 6.

They were 8 and 6.
I'm guessing he said 8 and 8 because that's 'level'.

just think about why, eh?

Ok, cool. I thought I had read 8 and 7 and when I saw your post saying 8 and 8 it made me almost sure. Carry on!

What's this now?

Any reasons Mr Dave?

A list. You should try it sometime.

He always has reasons. He doesn't often share them.

Mr Dave in cryptic MS posting shocker.

Is the reason "He's evil"?

Well, yes, but that doesn't mean he's one of the bad guys.

Oh, ho.

I do, however, think that such things can be quite revealing for those who have no external source of information.

I get where you're going with that Dave, but you should swap kalmar for Grim

We appear to have hit a bit of a lull. Have Runcle and Curio both went quiet? I was hoping we might get them a bit closer to the edge to try and prompt more discussion but instead we've gone backwards.

I can't see the connection, really.

Take Mr Russ - he's made only one post and hasn't voted. How are you correlating that with anyone else?

So that means you do have an external source of information, then?

A good swap in 99% of situations

Especially in a life-or-death-or-scottish situation

I am a quarter Scottish, of the proud McLeod clan.

Quarter Scottish off of the Bell clan.

But which is best?

Drink!

I'm not drinking Bells.

Well.. seems like noone else follows my Kalmar logic..

But - did make me realise that Runcle's response is also ignorant of the townie win condition so I still plump for him over Curio at this stage, also because if he is being good & honest then at least we aren't risking a town power role.
[vote: Runcle]

Okay, two votes to go for Runcle, two hours to find them.

Hmm, that seems awfully bloodthirsty...

It's nearly night time. We have to send someone out to di... try and save us all.

At risk of dragging this out further..

He said that him dying would be against his win condition. If he is a colonist, that is correct. So he is not ignorant of it.

Deliberately getting lynched would be acting against it though.

Nah, at this point of the game, there's no external information which anyone would care to give up. Which is part of the reason for posting now.
Other peoples lists would be more useful to me than my own.

Does that make you Immortal.

I'll have a list of things as well

Tuesday , Thursday , Tomorrow , Today

There we go isnt list making fun :-)

Still I suppose at least it isnt 4 word sentences.

Or lets pretend we're already dead and call out random players names as the baddies and at the end when we work out that 1 out of the 4 are bad we can claim we knew all along !

In that view : Kalmar , Joans , Terimahkaseh (hello - did you know a google of your name gives this forum as the 3rd hit) , and Gazchap

Only from the knees down