Be Excellent To Each Other

No, I genuinely haven't a clue. I've always sucked at this sort of thing.

Joans hasn't said anything today as far as I can tell, but I don't know if that makes him more or less likely to be one of them.

I am a mite worried about the quiet ones, such as Joans or Mr Dom.

Umm.. so what exactly is your specialisation? You regulate acids?
Sounds a bit wishy-washy...

You wouldn't be saying that if you'd had an incident with some acids that hadn't been regulated, I'll tell you that much.

Either you or Grim... ran out of ideas and just read the ingredients on the wrapper of whatever you were eating at the time.

Unregulated acids are the fourth most common cause of laboratory accidents, after irradiated insects, overregulated acids and reavers.

Soil acidity does need to be regulated. Plants get in a right strop if it's not done.

So is anyone else going to bother talking in here or is it just going to remain silent until everyone switches to Craster ?

Bit of catching up to do here. Don't do anything hasty, BRB.

Oh, my splitting sides.

Good enough for me. [vote: Bobbyaro]

I'm not getting into the whole Craster thing, he could be or he couldn't be, but there's definitely shiftier people around.

Morning , I'll nip out and get the milk ......

And just to check the reason for Curio voting Craster is "its a laugh" , and Myp is not around.

Not exactly sound reasoning

Is Bobby the only other viable candidate ?

Cylon Scum 2: Bleak dawn
VOTE UPDATE

gazchap: 1 (Mr Dave)
bobbyaro: 3 (Craster, Mr Dom, kalmar)
craster: 6 (LaceSensor, Mr Kissyfur, Malc, Mr Russell, Zeppo, GazChap)

Not voted: 6 (bobbyaro, curiosity, doctor glyndwr, joans, squirt, zaphod79)

With 16 players alive, 9 votes are required for a lynch, and 12 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

Hang on, so Craster is shifty and most people think he isn't a scientist. I am tempted to believe he is, hence me unvoting. Why does that make me suss?

Bear in mind that I have FOSed Mr Dom twice already, and now you are effectively defending him.

Yeah, exactly...
Seeing as I was the first to admit us scientists have a speciality (and having seeded my earlier posts about it too), FoSing me repeatedly does seem very scummy.

Oh, and what's your speciality?

Quick make something up!

I'm happy to get rid of anyone at the moment. Let's try pushing Bobby.

[vote:Bobbyaro]

Also, you have an Alien avatar

[vote: bobbyaro]

might as well

And your member title says "Die puny humans".

Case closed!

Right, the reason, I am inclined to believe Craster (and now actually Mr Dom, having read his previous comment, must have missed it earlier), is that my speciality follows the same trend as theirs. They are all linked. I have been loathe to mention this, for fear of giving something away, but mine Stem scientist.

We have Soil, seed, root, stem, leaf ...

As I say, I have not mentioned this, because of the fear of giving something away to the cylons. I was suss of LS, because his specialism wasn't plant based, but, he has roleclaimed pilot, so wouldn't have a specialism.

Acid.

You're just making one up that's a bit like the others, now.

And WTH would you have been giving away?

Hang on - those are only the role claimed ones - the *only* one we all know didnt even make your list



Thats very shakey logic your trying to use here.

Total metadata and probably shouldnt be mentioned but in case anyone is not aware of the history - Bobbys aliens avatar and comments came when he was outed as an alien in the game before last - it was quite funny at the time although i think he should probably have changed it before this one

I didn't have time to go through all of them, and frankly, Crasters of "acid" doesn't fit the list. I thought Craster's was "soil acidity", if it isn't, I would ask how it fits in the list.

Wouldn't it be funny if, someone who had previously claimed to have forgotten their specialism thanks to radiation, turned out to be a stem specialist and could presumably counterclaim against Bobbyaro.

Dawn comes, and it starts to rain again. Really, really warm rain, presumably due to the nuclear fallout. Sweet Chariot is still leaking. You can't really see that far away, so here's hoping the next Centurion along coughs or something, eh?

Bobby is very fixated on how everyone's science speciality must fit together, but there's no reason to believe that they should. We're on an arable planet, so most people will be plant-based, that doesn't mean everyone is, or that Craster is dodgy for being into acid, sorry, acids. And who would fixate on small details to try and wriggle off the hook he's dangling on? Someone scummy, is who.

[vote:bobbyaro]

I think we're all leaning towards nerfing Bobby now.

If we have an investigator, I'd love to know whether Craster's telling the truth or if he got his 'science specialty' off the back of a crisp packet.

Could be that the Sweet Chariot needs repairs before any of us have a chance of leaving...

*starts foraging for leaves capable of withstanding vacuum*

Bobbyaro is certainly looking more dodgy than Craster at the moment. Acids are certainly varied and plentiful enough that I can see the logic in having a scientist specialising in researching them.

Stems? Unless we're talking about stem cells (which we're plainly not, as Bobby claims they are all plant-related) then that just seems far too obtuse.

[vote:Bobbyaro]

In fact, the more I think of this, the less it seems as clear cut as thought.
1) Craster made a vague reference to scientists on the first page - as any reasonable cylon would KNOWING there were scientists involved.
2) His science type does not match any other declared type.

[vote:craster]

Oh, and remember this one as well, I fos gazchap, no he is counter claiming me, with THIS??? FFS. FGaz chap and craster on the same side.

Indeed. Which is indicative of the fact I'm telling the truth rather than just looking for a pattern and making up one that fits, hmmm? Like a 'stem scientist'?

Just read this one as well! What?? I give up, you people are idiots, you have a clear list of science types, defining a plant, and one anomaly of "acid" and you are believing "acid", despite KNOWING that SDG was photosynthesis.

Also, if required, ignore this debate and go back to why I voted for Craster in the first place. His vote for Kovacs yesterday, a clear scum tell.

You started the vote for Kovacs!!

As it happens, I reckon one of you is a Cylon and the other the Psycho, so I'm not fussed which one we send packing.

I am a scientist, a Stem specialist, we are defining a plant, from roots to tip, maybe growth, maybe it is a hidden code allowing us to find Earth and escape if we all work together, I don't know. What I DO know, is that Craster does not fit in this code.

That makes him different to humans, therefore is most likely a cylon.

I thought you believed I was a scientist?

as covered previously, not the vote itself, the manor of the vote. Stop trying to muddy the waters.

I'm muddying nothing. You started a bandwagon on Kovacs, then somehow turn that on me for saying "well, we need to kill someone, and Kovacs has votes" - which is entirely to be expected on day 1 when there's nothing else to go on.

No, I voted for Kovacs, a few more people voted, then you jumped on an easy bandwagon.

Hmmm. You're both hugly suspect now. Happy to go for Bobby and then do Crster tomorrow if Bobby turns out to have been sent packing into the rain for no good reason. Craster will then have been a chief instigator of two bandwagons against innocents and so will be pretty much cast-iron proven to be scum.

[vote:Bobbyaro]

VOTE UPDATE

gazchap: 1 (Mr Dave)
craster: 4 (Malc, Mr Russell, Zeppo, Bobbyaro)
bobbyaro: 8 (LaceSensor, Mr Kissyfur, Craster, Mr Dom, GazChap, kalmar, Curiosity, Doctor Glyndwr)

Not voted: 3 (joans, squirt, zaphod79)

With 16 players alive, 9 votes are required for a lynch, and 12 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

Ha! I chipped in with a standalone vote against Kovacs. "Chief instigator of bandwagons" indeed. And I'm only really voting for Bobby because he's voting for me, frankly.

Oh, and if you're still alive tomorrow morning, you and Curio are both lying scummers.

I didn't roleclaim, Bobby. I simply said it would be funny if I was a stem specialist and could counterclaim.

Your reaction is pretty telling, a couple of typos in your first react-o-post as if you're typing really quickly to avoid a rush of votes.

Anyway, as scummy as this is going to sound, I'm a Scientist. My memory loss must have been short term as I've now recalled that I'm a Meteorologist. A weather forecaster.

How does that fit into your Plant Code, Mr. Cylon?

Whatever, toaster.

I wouldn't put it past the Cylons to leave either me or Curio alive tonight to get one of us lynched tomorrow and draw attention away from certain quarters.

Lol. Nice try. They'll leave Curio alive, but you, an investigator? I think not.

What does typing quickly have to do with anything? Kovacs barely typed a word right and he was military.

Frankly, your returning memory is interesting, what is more interesting is your roleclaim as cylon!




The comment about radiation was aimed at you for "addling your electronic mind" Radiation would not affect a human mind causing memory loss!

[vote:gazchap]

FFS, he has cocked up people!

If indeed that is my real name.

I do have a slight horrible feeling that the real Cylons are people like Mr Dom, Joans and Mr Dave... and they are currently laughing at us.