Joans wrote:
I still stand by my argument that we should have lynched trooper because if we hadn't, we'd be doubting him for the rest of the game.
Yes, because it's always good to get rid of another townie.
Joans wrote:
I knew Curio was lying, but had no idea if Grim... was the real doctor or not, I just liked what he was saying.
How, exactly, did you know that Curio was lying?
Bobbyaro wrote:
Goddess Jasmine be a fine figure of a woman, but that doesn't mean she is not hiding a murderous heart. The main piece of evidence I have against her is her rather lame defence of her voting for Mr Russ. Coupled with this:
Curiosity AKA MAfia Don wrote:
GJ started the lynch on Russ, but I think it'd be rare for the Mafia to be so bold so early on in trying to get a bandwagon rolling.
So the Maaafia Don be deflecting aaaatention aaaaway from you, eh?
I didn't have a lame defence, I justified my vote which obviously more than one person agreed with, it wasn't so lame then was it?
As for Curio's comment, even as a mafia you have opinions about people, and I am not going to even attempt to defend what someone else has said!
gospvg wrote:
sinister agent wrote:
I'm not sure I understand the reasoning behind voting for Joans.
If he were mafia, why would he have denied being protected/roleblocked when curio claimed it? It would have been smarter to 'confirm' Curio's claim, surely?
Good point but did Curio must have know that he was going to get lynched so Joans wanted to protect himself?
I agree with this, it was obvious when Curio roleclaimed that he would be found out that night one way or another, why lose another mafia as well?
gospvg wrote:
I want to hear from Goddess on why we should not vote for her?
Because we don't need to lose another townie.
Having just read Flis' post, I don't think she is scummy, although I don't know who to vote for really. I'm tempted to go for Dave or Gilly simply as neither of them have really contributed (Dave moreso) but then obviously that doesn't really tell us anything either and would split the vote further.