Be Excellent To Each Other

That should be a super secret role in the next day



(not explicitly included in the rules but given out as a special to some other player - if they make people believe they are really that role , or get the true roleclaimer killed then they win their role regardless of what happens next)

Has one ever worked out?

I've survived one more night a couple of times, and sewn doubt and confusion.

Also, lots of fun.

Nobs have gone and hung Trooper.

Stupid townies.

Stupid me.

So there's one dead townie we wouldn't have had without my lies!

:-D

I assume I was right, and you knew he was protected because you tried to off him?

*waves*

Well, that was great fun!
Damn you Curio!

I assume you made a good guess after my post on the third day that I had an idea on who the Doc was, as one way of having that idea was to be investigated. Or, of course, it was just blind luck

I "knew' Grim was the doc after that investigation and our posts during the previous day, and was waiting for him to post pointers from then on, but Curio's evidence was pretty convincing. I was 50/50 when I started writing my post over my vote justification, but halfway through writing it, it felt like way too much of a coincidence to be anything other than the truth.

I even sent that to Davpaz to post for me, as I thought it was going to be a whitewash and I might not even get time to post.

Weirdly, nobody even questioned the fact that I said I had been protected overnight, there was no evidence, and no way of getting evidence to that, and they thought I was mafia anyway, so why believe me?

No, because they got a kill that night.

I refuse to believe Curio got a lucky guess.

Errr... town guys, unless the mafia offed their own boss, then curio had to be the MS.
Either they are being total belmers, or sowing weird thoughts...

I might be good to run a game where all bets are off and people can do what they like and use whatever info they like

I was stunned by that too. I had to check my list.

It was an educated lucky guess, I, er, guess, from having Trooper say that he thought he knew who the doctor was.

Why are they belming on about serial killers? It'd be the worst serial killer ever*. I gave them a list of bad people (and Trooper). Grumble.

*I confess that I originally thought Kalmar had been done by an SK due to the description, but that was until Curio was revealed to be a second Mafia Don.

It would be great to have a power role next time, and to not do anything for the first 4-5 days

That was my intention.

Trooper was an educated guess, but not for the reason you thought. It was because he challenged me so directly about who had been doctored. I knew days 1 and 3, and he seemed, by that challenge to know who it was on Day 2, so it had to be him.

Not bad guessing skills to get him AND replace the Mafia Don on the second night!

This has been a game of epic guesses - not only from you, but from the Cop (not a good one, obviously), and I got the 2/3 'attacking' mafia folk

Ah! I think that was incredibly lucky then, as it just so happened I was around at the time and the one to challenge you to declare, if I hadn't been first then someone else would have been quick to do that, as it was the very obvious next step!

Going from your earlier comment in all the games so far this was the first one I was a baddie , I played the first day the exact same way I would as a goodie and was randomly chosen by the cop :-)

This obviously goes back to the 'go for anyone on Day 1 cause you might get lucky'

See, this is what happens when you kill all the talkative souls...

Bless 'em. They have no idea what's going on.

They could look back at the past few days and see who the known good people had suspicions about, and go from there...

Nobody has picked up on the fact that Lace always talks about food, not sure what that means but that is partly was got my FOS up...

If there's any logic in there currently, it's lost on me.

I think that is a trifle unfair! Hardly belmy to side with the first person to say they were the doc, and to tell me info that only he and I could have known, if I didn't already have the suspicion that Grim... was the doc, then it would have been cut and dried from the start. The only reason the masses sided against me was because they didn't know I was a townie, if they knew that, then they would have all sided with me and Grim... would have been a gonna

Yup "lets not vote anyone". Do what now?

Sinister's logic is impeccable, yet for some reason he still feels scummy to me...

I would bet my life (if I still had one) on Lace being scum.

Sinister's logic is always impeccable. I reckon he has charts.

Jesus. Night of the Long Posts.

They are both on my Scum list. As is Gosvpg.

I am loving Bobby's character.

And also our sleeper agent...

Dude, that was you.

There can't be four of them left?

Mr Dave? Great tactic if so, hide behind playing like a total idiot

Except he keeps voting for Gosvpg, of course.

Sure, and has done from the start for the most spurious of reasons, and I think Gos is a townie.

I believe, sir, you are a wrongun.
And we may be about to find out for sure.

Still nobody believes i'm good, what do I have to do!

KILL SOMEONE YOU IDIOTS!

Bloody noose cost £20. Not getting our money's worth.

Do an emmerdale style catastrophe, and introduce a load of new characters tomorrow

I think Gosvpg is dead. Lace voted for him, but it didn't count.

I'm not sure why.

Ah shit. He spelled it wrong. Shall I let it stand?

Ah, spelling mistake. Down to you to make the call on this one, DavPaz.

Typo!

Good question, I think you should be a stickler for the rules and it doesn't count, after all it could have been intended and a very clever move...

Stand by.

Plus it will teach the town not to be such pussies

Tricky one. I'd take it as a proper vote, I think. Unless he misspelt it on purpose, which I would say is pushing close to cheating.

Result stands.