Be Excellent To Each Other

You can't be investigated....you're in jail.

Jailed people can't be targeted for night actions. You can be hung with a pair of Slightly Greens knickers or stabbed with an improvised shank or have your head caved in against the toilet but that is all.

So do we think Superman has been arresting or investigating? I hope investigating as everyone in jail isn't much help to us. I also hope B-Man has been investigating too, Robin isn't much use for anything as he dies so easily so the more investigating they do now, before Batman gets potentially offed, the better.

Lex will just try killing everyone until he is dead. If he gets a super and roleblocks them, he's not going to be too bothered is he? He can't risk trying to eliminate Superman until he finds all the supers and the only way he could deduce which one he's found would be if we managed to lynch some of the other bad guys.

Best place for all the bad guys is jail. If the investigators find a bad guy one night, throw him in jail the next....If any of the investigators turn up anyone with the primary win con of "Kill Superman", they should come forward so we can lynch Lex, they can then either be protected by rescued Superman.

There's no rush on a lynch; we've still got ages to go.

I did throw in the last vote on DavPaz; and I knew it would throw suspicion on me, which is why I posted a couple of times between him being on the block and him getting lynched.

Not sure why Mr Russ is jumping at me so vociferously though. The same accusations could be pointed at anyone who voted for him, especially the first few and the last few.

Because you twice voted for gazchap by saying he was one of the quiet ones, despite saying no more than him yourself.

Ummm... you might want to count the posts made by each of us, fella.

And my vote for him today was based on sound logic that he might be a bad guy, which everyone has agreed with.

Massive FOS on you, sir.

Hopefully Joans will come out & speak, after all that is the purpose of the vote.

To be fair, I seem to recall that Curio has said more than Gazchap. He was (correct me if wrong) suggesting we go for a quiet person pretty consistently, which is a strategy I agree with.

Thanks, I did.

One post on day 1.
6 posts on day 2.

True but only the henchmen knew who the other henchmen were able to talk to each other, all the other bad guys have no comms unless Superman gets knobbled with black Kryptonite and become a cool bad ass Superman, at which point him and Lex can talk. So this means that as long as Curio isn't a final henchman he wouldn't have a clue who the other bad guys are, so it would have been a shot in the dark....unless he is evil/good and had a investigate on him and decided to off a henchman...Joker need everyone dead to win doesn't he?

But DavPaz was a henchman so does not matter if your vote was first or last it was correct.

Yep, if you're trying to throw suspicion onto another quiet person, you only need by slightly louder than him yourself. Now Sinister, I don't know why you're defending Curio (albeit only logically) because I can see no way you'd be in cahoots with him.

You are therefore possibly just an innocent bystander trying to make sense of things.

You can juwt compare the number of times they've posted. I could post in here constantly, saying "hmm, I wonder who to lynch" etc., which offers nothing to the conversation or someone come in twice a day and make a vilid and reasoned contribution, yet you'd lynch them based on post count....? That logic does not wash with me.

There seems to be only a few of us talking at the moment, thus I think the tactic of voting for a quiet player is a good way to get them to talk. I'm away for a while so don't lynch Joans until they have talked.

Can't compare, not can....stupid fat fingers on my stupid phone.

Agreed it's the content of the post that is us

How about if I say lynch him because he's Brainiac?

Stupid tapatalk !!
I was going to say it's the content & not quantity of the posts.

Who? Curio?

Yeah. But he could be Lex Luthor instead.

Either way that would make him evil & lynch-able.

You could of course be double bluffing ?

Have you investigated?

[vote:Curiosity]

And now for some actual content, Russell, are you saying you've investigated Curio?

Yeah, that's partly why I want to wait until I can read through everything before voting - people can post lots without actually saying much.

As for defending Curio, well I'm just trying to weigh possibilities up, really. SG's post is fair, also (though I should add that unless I'm being a div, evil superman can't exist yet as LL has been killing), as if Curio is evil that either means he's a henchman (surely the last, assuming there are any left) saving himself, or a villain shrugging and piling on.

A villain wouldn't need to pile on with one vote to go - it's not worth the exposure for someone who's about to swing anyway. So if curio's evil he's probably the last henchman. But that would mean there were loads to begin with, and the only thing making me think there might be one left is that Davpaz suggested there isn't. Which is a bit thin.

In conclusion: Iono. I will probably go back to voting for Joans just to provoke a response later, but I want to read back over the days first.

Well, why would you say that? There are a limted number of ways you could work that out. It is possible you are telling the truth, of course. You also realise saying that means you'd get lynched tomorrow if he isn't? Would you prefer jail or protection if he does turn out to be brainiac?

Oh and I didn't read brainiacs win con before, I had though Lex was the only one with that win con...

And I thought Brainiac was the only one with that win condition.
Yep, he got done investigated. By me.

[vote:curiosity]

And protect me tonight please!

[vote:curiosity]

Interesting, because I was protected by Superman, and as such you couldn't have investigated me.

[vote:mr russell]

Oh to see Curiosity swing
Will be such a sweet thing

It's true he is bad
But what fun we have had

Superman, please touch me there
Yeah.

Okay, that's good enough for me, but I still don't want to rush lynch yet with, what, three days to go?

Will check up from home in an hour or two.

Mr Russell, seeing how you have already claimed to be an investigating role, care to tell us which one you are?

Awesome!

Superman, he's trying to draw you out to deny his claim, therefore he's most likely to be Lex rather than Brainiac.

Do I have to?

Who else did you investigate, Russ?

So he could equally be Lex then? So did you roleblock him one night as well, as that is the only way you'd know he was Brainiac and not Lex...or does anyone else want to own up to that?

If you have only investigated him, he could be either or. Whichever way, it is better either of them are dead!

If you're protected, we lose more than just your night actions....we all (except you) become sitting ducks with no evidence to go on tomorrow. I'd sorta rather you were jailed for your own safety and our future wellbeing. No offence

[vote:curiosity]

Good enough for me

[vote:curiosity]

I would suggest we do as he says, if Curio isn't evil we can always have a quick day tomorrow

[vote:unvote]

I have to go out now but I'll be back and cast my vote later

MESSAGE TO SUPERMAN, DO NOT CONFIRM OR DENY WHAT CURIO SAID.

Caps because it's super important.

Mr Russell, yes it is. You could easily be the Joker.

Someone innocent.
Rather not say as I can use the info if someone tries to vote against them.

I would suggest you probably shouldn't.

Yes true if he is not evil then Russ for the chopping block

I'm not trying to draw out Superman, I am just stating a fact.

Superman was with me, so Mr Russell MUST be lying.

Ultimately, I'm only a bystander so it doesn't matter too much if you waste a lynch on me... but Mr Russell is a dirty liar, and Superman knows this.

Both nights.....?

If you were protected one night, that could be the night Brainiac didn't kill. Russ could have investigated you another night.

Russ, you don't have to roleclaim but I would still rather you were in jail.

Oh. Hehe. (Well I was looking for the Alan Partridge clip), but I'm the world's greatest detective.

SuperScum 2 : Day 3

VOTE UPDATE

mr russell: 1 (Curiosity)
gazchap: 1 (kalmar)
curiosity: 4 (Mr Russell, Slightly Green, Jon.J, flis)

Not voted: 8 (alarm, gazchap, goddess jasmine, gospvg, grim..., joans, kovacsc, sinister agent)

With 14 players alive, 8 votes are required for a lynch, and 11 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

...
I can see that, but if you die tonight it's been wasted. Unless they're a super, of course.

That's fairly convincing, as such:
[vote: curiosity]

That's why it would nice if I was protected tonight, as I can carry on investigating.

Supes was only with me last night.

Mr Russell could have investigated me on Night One, but then he wouldn't be trying to string me up, as he would know I'm innocent.

By the way he's been after me today, it's clear he is pretending he investigated me last night. When he didn't.

I know I'll be lynched, but Mr Russ is your Joker, and you need to kill him.

If Russ is Batman then I have 2 things to do

a) [vote: curiosity]

B) are you a superhero?

I see what you're saying.....

[vote:unvote]

Mr Russell, are you or are you not claiming to be Batman?

Curio, if Mr Russell is a dirty liar then not only does Superman know but so do Batman and Robin.

Unvoted because I don't want the day to end before everyone checks into the thread.