All Saints? could we see the first nil-pointer of the Beexovision song contest?

It's already got 4 points!



Malc

You can say many things about All Saints, but one thing's for sure - that cover version is far, far better than the original.

Luddites. Respec' to whoever posted that one, I say.

Also - Chili Peppers suck balls.

Luddites. Respec' to whoever posted that one, I say.

Also - Chili Peppers suck balls.

RHCP fans suck balls too.

One very good album, and the occasional good song off the next 2, then the same song again and again.

Same applies to Foofighters.

Noooo, not the Foo's aswell! They are great

Linkin Park is the ultimate band though...ever

Linkin Park is the ultimate band though...ever

You're kidding, right?

You're kidding, right?

I like lots of bands that lots of people seem to dislike.

This does not bother me.

As long as I like it, why should I care what other people think?

Malc

RHCP song checklist:

Alright guitar riff: Check
Lyrics that at speed sound like "hedihbeh hedibeh ebleb blaw blaw": Check

Congrats, you have a RHCP song

While that pretty much holds true, of course, Under The Bridge is one track that doesn't fit it.

While that pretty much holds true, of course, Under The Bridge is one track that doesn't fit it.

And, funnily enough, it's even shitter than the regular RHCP songs. Saved only by the Saints' cover of it.

Shin - you, literally, disgust me. Linkin Park.

Absolutely spot on. There are loads of bands I like, that others think are shit, and things I don't like that people like. Doesn't bother me.

what does bother me though, is the opposite, people liking a band because it is cool to like the band, not because of their music, and I feel to some extent that RHCP are beginning to fall into this category*. Which is a shame. I blame Radio 1 wholly for this.

*see also Marilyn Manson, Foofighters, the whole Oasis/Blur battle of years gone by, etc.

Anyway, this is completely off topic, maybe a mod should edit this to the general discussion?

See, I like all those bands. and bands like Linkin Park (tho not as much as it appears Shin does), Sum41, AAF, Nickleback, Kaiser Chiefs, The Killers, Keene, Coldplay, Razorlight, The Streets, I could go on.

Now, I don't go out looking for bands, I listen to stuff on the radio, and on music TV, and on launch. I don't listen to Radio 1, 2, or anything like that. I listen to Absolute Radio, (which used to be virgin radio) and I happen to like listening to that sort of stuff.

Malc

Damn I had a big response typed up, but lost it. Sod it.

The gist(sp?) was: I like songs from all of those bands too, but not every song by those bands. Some people can't accept any criticism of a song if it is by band X. I find this annoying. That is all I was trying to say, not that liking band X is bad. I suppose you could say I don't like band waggons!
No?

No one?

Pah!

You're quite right Bobby - it's a song war, not a band war.

I like the Crash Test Dummies.

SClub7>>>>Girls Aloud

Five are even better.

Five are even better.